Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

would riding with back pain be good idea or bad?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • DaUniGuy
    replied
    Originally posted by MUCFreerider View Post
    Again I think the best guide is listening to your body. If riding hurts at all or just doens't feel right (e.g. makes your back all tense and tight) then don't.
    Good advice for any strenuous activity. Especially once the years start to add up.

    Leave a comment:


  • MUCFreerider
    replied
    I concur that unicycling is about the best activity for my back and since I started unicycling almost all of my back problems virtually disappeared (I also sit on a petzi ball at my desk and these 2 things are my treatment again back pain). As has been said, the upright position is good, it requires you to actively use all kinds of different muscles in your back (for forward/backward/sideways balance and rotation). And the impacts are minimal (unless you're doing large drops or big trials moves. Exception: This year when doing frequent >1m drops I noticed the back doesn't like it so much). If I go more than 3-4 days without being on the uni I can feel my back is tight and in need of a good unicycle ride.

    Originally posted by wfcentral View Post
    On a recent trip I slightly injured my back - pulled a muscle or something. I can stand / sit / etc... just a bit sore when I try to bend at the waist.
    ...So - question now is... should I stay away from uni until back is 100% healed or would riding it and stretching those back muscles be a good thing?
    However, if you have an active muscle tear then it might be better to rest for a week to 10 days or so. I would say the feeling should guide you. If you can feel the torn muscle when you get on the unicycle, then don't ride. From your description it sounds like upright posture is no problem.

    Then you have to consider what happens when you UPD: As you can't predict if you will suddenly have your upper body violently pushed forward or back, it's hard to predict. I've over-extended my back on a few falls as well as had a few small muscle tears from UPDs. If you can't bend forward without pain, then how will you UPD to the front (or only limit your riding to stuff where you have a very low chance of UPD, but this wouldn't work well for me as I would get bored nd started "playing" soon anyway).

    Not quite my back, but my side: I had a strange injury earlier this year (posted about it and most people said to see a doctor) which was rather strange. It felt kind of like a muscle tear under my front/side ribcage but then wasn't like most in that it wasn't sore to touch. Anyhow, resting didn't seem to help much (10 days with no unicycling) and I eventually just kept riding and it finally went away.

    Again I think the best guide is listening to your body. If riding hurts at all or just doens't feel right (e.g. makes your back all tense and tight) then don't.

    Leave a comment:


  • leo
    replied
    Originally posted by OneTrackMind View Post
    Repetitive running impacts are far worse than riding over a few bumps on a uni.
    Still I'm always amazed it's so difficult to convince a corpulent person that cycling or swimming are better options for their bones, while running -in such case- is almost a certain subscription to injury. "But running is more common, so must be better - the majority can't be wrong."

    Leave a comment:


  • LanceB
    replied
    While I recognize that anecdotal evidence is statistically insignificant, I have had bad disks since the 80s, with periodic bouts of pain ranging from simply sore to bed-ridden. Since I've started unicycle riding I have had almost no instances of back pain, and I find that the more I ride the better my back feels. I find muni to be better, which may seem counter-intuitive, since it's generally rougher. I think it's because in muni the back is in almost constant motion. Road riding is more of a steady repetition, so somewhat less beneficial (for me, anyway) (but I still do a lot of road riding, 'cause I like it).
    Just my opinion, "Your Mileage May Vary!"

    Leave a comment:


  • OneTrackMind
    replied
    Originally posted by leo View Post
    One not unrelated problem I think is not addressed by barely any unicyclist is that the foam used in nowedays seats isn't having much memory capacity.
    And even if it had, the suspension it provides is IMHO too mininal, even for unicycle rides on the best cyclepaths in the world.
    Keep in mind that anything unequal on the riding surface will cause some impact on the spine. A zillion times minimal impact may result in backpain, and in that case increasing your rides will increase your pain.
    There is impact involved even with walking. Repetitive running impacts are far worse than riding over a few bumps on a uni.

    Moreover, the uni rider uses their legs as the suspension quite effectively.

    Leave a comment:


  • aracer
    replied
    Originally posted by leo View Post
    While writing I was wondering somethinge else; could he be credited for inventing flat seats?
    Indeed he can:
    http://www.unicyclist.com/forums/showthread.php?t=95551

    Unless anybody else wants to try and claim credit - but that's the first I knew of the idea (though I'd like to claim a little credit for helping them become more widespread )

    Leave a comment:


  • leo
    replied
    Nice to read a number of replies I'd expected (confiming unicycling is a good activity to get rid of back pain).
    Most useful reply made me itch to contribute some additions to.

    Originally posted by johnfoss View Post
    Unicycling strengthens your lower back.
    Not only that -in general- (as said) make you sit straight up automatically. Reason: it's the most energy-efficient position while unicycling, so; you do this out of lazyness!

    Originally posted by johnfoss View Post
    That said, we are not doctors (give or take a Ken Looi or two)
    There must be at least one PT plus an IMT person here, who I would trust at least as much on these matters.

    Originally posted by johnfoss View Post
    Ken Looi
    While writing I was wondering somethinge else; could he be credited for inventing flat seats? Or is that something that I fabricated in my memory?

    Originally posted by johnfoss View Post
    no two backs are alike.
    Even if the sympthones or state may be alike, what usually matters most is the cause, or better said the root of the problem.

    One not unrelated problem I think is not addressed by barely any unicyclist is that the foam used in nowedays seats isn't having much memory capacity.
    And even if it had, the suspension it provides is IMHO too mininal, even for unicycle rides on the best cyclepaths in the world.
    Keep in mind that anything unequal on the riding surface will cause some impact on the spine. A zillion times minimal impact may result in backpain, and in that case increasing your rides will increase your pain.

    Originally posted by johnfoss View Post
    But also take doctor advice with a grain of salt.
    So finding a doctor here -with unicycling knowledge- is a great idea - but doing consults online in general isn't.

    Leave a comment:


  • 1x1 offroader
    replied
    To state the obvious...

    Falling off mightn't help your back!

    Leave a comment:


  • Mikefule
    replied
    I have occasional episodes of severe back pain. It goes from 0% pain to 100% pain and from free movement to severely limited mobility in an instant. I believe it is a muscular spasm rather than skeletal.

    I have from time to time visited physios and the like. I feel that they have charged me money to keep me occupied until I recovered naturally.

    Once I had one of these sudden episodes 12 miles out on an "out and back" ride, and I was on my own.

    I tried to walk back pushing the uni and soon concluded it was never going to work. I then mounted against a pole, slowly straightened my back, and rode smoothly. Every dismount for a gate or stile was a problem but the actual riding was easier than walking.

    It didn't make things better or worse than they usually are with such an episode.

    Leave a comment:


  • aracer
    replied
    Try it and see if it hurts. I actually hurt my back unicycling, and found that most riding made it worse whilst it was badly injured. Though a lot of people on here seem to find it helps, so clearly experiences vary and it depends what sort of injury you have. Also on what sort of riding - I'd be fairly conservative and not do anything too extreme.

    Leave a comment:


  • johnfoss
    replied
    Unicycling strengthens your lower back. That said, we are not doctors (give or take a Ken Looi or two), and no two backs are alike. What works for one rider may not necessarily be viable, or even a good idea, for someone else.

    But also take doctor advice with a grain of salt. Riding a typical road or mountain bike puts your back at a very different angle than unicycling, and can also be harmful, depending on your condition. Basic unicycling has your back upright, with what is essentially "good posture". It's not a bent-over thing that a doctor might warn against, because this can strain a lower back...

    Leave a comment:


  • anton005
    replied
    When my back starts to act up riding almost always makes it feel better. Give it a try, take it easy and see what happens.

    Leave a comment:


  • pstrick
    replied
    Nearly all back pain is managed conservatively with physical therapy. Riding may be just the thing! But like any other activity, start slowly, see how it goes, and increase your time gradually.

    Leave a comment:


  • wfcentral
    started a topic would riding with back pain be good idea or bad?

    would riding with back pain be good idea or bad?

    I'm 52 years old. Have been riding for about 2 years. I was riding about 3-4 days a week for 4 miles. Then, life got busy and changes in my schedule... so, have only ridden one time in last 30 days.

    On a recent trip I slightly injured my back - pulled a muscle or something. I can stand / sit / etc... just a bit sore when I try to bend at the waist.

    Makes me mad that I did not find the time to keep riding as I know I have benefited from the core strength the uni has given me.

    So - question now is... should I stay away from uni until back is 100% healed or would riding it and stretching those back muscles be a good thing?
Working...
X